Lack of home sales in Emerald Hills wreaks havoc with home values…
It’s a Tough Year
As you’ll see in next week’s Emerald Hills Report Card for April, this continues to be a brutally tough year if you’re selling a home in Emerald Hills. Without even looking at the final numbers for April, I can tell you that nothing significant happened this past month that will pull the region any closer to the sales level of previous years. Obviously, this is not the news you want to hear if you already have a home on the market.
But what’s important to note is that this dearth of home sales also creates a secondary level of problem: Estimating home values. Here’s why…
No Comparable Sales…
One of the common ways to establish the value of a home, whether you’re selling a home or you’re an appraiser, is to look for other homes that have recently sold in the area that are similar in size and features. These are referred to as sales comparables, or “comps” for short. While it’s not the only way to establish the value of a home, it’s by far the most commonly used in a normal, healthy real estate market. The more relevant comps you can gather, the more accurate you can peg the value of a home.
But what happens when there are very few comps, just like we’re seeing now in Emerald Hills? The process then becomes much more subjective, and a lot less accurate. In order to find a relevant home sale, you’ll have to either
- Search further away in proximity from the home in question, or
- Look much further back in time to find these sales figures, or
- Both
You can see the potential for inaccuracy when this happens. Different neighborhoods carry different values, even within Emerald Hills. And when you’re living in a falling market such as this one, looking back more than 3 months at homes sales data really calls the validity of this data into question.
Appraisals?
It’s obvious to see how this situation makes it difficult for a seller and their agent to price a home properly. But another problem that’s not so obvious is getting the home appraised once it’s in contract. With all of the extra scrutiny by the banks on every deal, appraisals are more closely watched than ever before. Consequently, it’s quite conceivable that a home may NOT appraise at the sales price — not because it’s not worth the price, but because the appraiser can’t gather enough data to justify the price to the bank.
The New Gold Standard.
Whether it’s right or wrong, when a home finally does sell in a given area, its sales price immediately “resets the bar” for the value of all similar homes that are on the market. While that wouldn’t necessarily be the case in a busy market, it carries much more weight now, simply because there’s no data to compare it to. Here’s a good example:
611 Lombardy Way is a 4 bedroom, 3-bath, 3,410 square foot home on a 12,196 square foot lot that just went into contract after being reduced to $1,495,000. Assuming for now that this transaction closes escrow at this price, this now becomes the “gold standard” for all homes that are similar in size, features, and proximity. Comparable homes that are priced significantly above this mark (and there are a quite a few) will now have a tough time justifying a premium with savvy buyers, and quite possibly appraisers, when this new comp becomes the sole datapoint in this area.
Until the sales volume picks up again in Emerald Hills, one can probably expect to see a ton of volatility in home values.
————————————————————————-


















